Filed under: You Have Chosen Have Chris Carpenter Punch Brandon Phillips Square In The Jaw. By Alex Fritz Apr 20, 2011, 8:00pm CDT Share this story Share this on Facebook Share this on Twitter Share All sharing options Share All sharing options for: You Have Chosen Have Chris Carpenter Punch Brandon Phillips Square In The Jaw. Reddit Pocket Flipboard Email Chris Carpenter punches out Brandon Phillips. Chris Carpenter leaves the game with a broken right hand and never pitches again.↵Kansas City Royals trade (SP) Jeff Suppan to the Saint Louis Cardinals for Shelby Miller.